We research and handpick every product we recommend. Still, we may earn commissions from purchases made through our links. Learn more.

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich [List of 18 Ideas]

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich
Share on:

Requiring nothing more than just throwing it in the middle of two bread slices spruced up with some lettuce and cheese, they give you heaven in just a few minutes. Still, even the best ideas could use improvement, which in this case is saucing it up. So what sauces go with a chicken sandwich?

There are plenty of sauces that fit perfectly well with a chicken sandwich. Honey mustard sauce, lemon and garlic, mayo and curry, marinara, barbeque sauce, garlic, lemon, parsley, tzatziki, tartar sauce, sweet marinara, Alfredo sauce, and honey and beer sauce are among the best chicken sandwich sauces. 

In the following paragraphs, I will give you some ideas about sauces you can combine with your chicken sandwich. 

Best Sauce for Fried Chicken Sandwich 

Fried chicken sandwiches are juicy and more than a bit fatty and greasy. They are flavorful, slightly crispy, and an absolute delight. The sauces that follow make the fried chicken sandwich even juicier, complementing and enhancing the flavors. 

Honey Mustard

Honey mustard sauce is one of the best pairs for fried chicken and is, therefore, often served with chicken nuggets and wings. The measurements are pretty loose, but make sure you balance the flavor nicely so that the honey flavor doesn’t dominate but simply follows the tone set by the mustard. 

In addition to honey mustard, you will also need some salt and pepper and possibly a little water if the sauce gets too thick. Some people like adding ketchup to their honey mustard sauce, so you can also try this variant. 

Lemon Garlic 

Made with nothing more than lemon juice, garlic, and some oil, this sauce is a delight for fried chicken sandwiches. Easy to make and deliciously complementing the fried chicken sandwich, the garlic and lemon combination adds its magic to the story and accentuates the flavors already included in the sandwich. 

Adding pickles or olives to your fried chicken sandwich is nice to complement the lemon and garlic flavors. Requiring nothing more than squeezing the lemon, mincing the garlic, and topping them with oil to bond the ingredients, you will have a delicious and zesty sauce in just under a minute. 

Mayo and Curry 

Mayo and curry flavors go hand in hand with fried chicken sandwiches. Very versatile, incredibly flavorful, and amazingly compatible, these two ingredients do wonders together. 

You will need nothing more than just curry and mayo mixed well together so that the curry powder equally disperses through the mayo consistency. This sauce requires some serious elbow grease while mixing, but it is worth it, as good mixing makes the mayo consistency less pungent and more pleasant to eat. 

Best Sauce for Grilled Chicken Sandwich 

Grilled chicken is one of the most universal and versatile sandwich ingredients. It goes with every salad, sauce, and condiment. Even though you can combine a grilled chicken sandwich with most of the sauces you can think of, the ones below are some of the best.

Barbeque Sauce 

The Carolina BBQ sauce is one of the best sauces for grilled chicken sandwiches made with hot sauce, red pepper, spices, and vinegar. It works best when made ahead of time, so it has enough time to set in the fridge. 

All you need to do is mix the ingredients, adding the vinegar last and the hot sauce first. Dosage the spices so that none of them dominates by adding them slowly and trying the sauce frequently. 

This sauce is also durable, so you can make a jar and keep it in the fridge for a week to enjoy all the grilled chicken sandwiches you can eat. 

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich

Soy Sauce With Herbs and Honey

If you don’t feel particularly creative but would like to indulge yourself with a delicious chicken sandwich and sauce combo, this one is the right fit for you. Mixing the recognizable soy tang with the sweetness of the honey and the natural and earthy notes of the herbs will bring your grilled chicken sandwich to another level. 

You will have absolutely no trouble making this sauce if you call for nothing more than basic cooking skills. Mix the honey and soy sauce well, add the honey and the soy sauce second, and add the herbs at the end. 

Garlic, Lemon, and Parsley 

Mix melted butter with minced garlic and parsley, and top the mixture with a few freshly squeezed lemon drops, and you are good to go. The butteriness of the sauce will tone down the intensity of the lemon and garlic components while accentuating the parsley flavor. 

Whether you smear the sauce on your sandwich buns or simply dunk your sandwich after every bite, you will love the liveliness this sauce adds to your sandwich. 

Best Sauce for Deli Chicken Sandwich 

Deli chicken sandwich holds the hearts of many as it is one of the most common meals ever. Whether you are running late for work and have a bite on the go or you need a quick lunch in the middle of a busy day, the deli chicken sandwich is always a delicious idea to fill your stomach. 

Mayo and Mustard

Mayo and mustard fall under the “ridiculously simple” sauce category. Considering this mixture’s deliciousness, there is no chance you would believe it is so easy to make. Mix the mayo and mustard together and your dosage of the ingredients to balance the flavors, and you are good to go. 

Tomato Sauce (Marinara)

Marinara sauce is an excellent idea to enrich your deli chicken sandwich if you have some free time. Just blend a few tomatoes and simmer them over hot oil in a saucepan. Season with garlic and herbs, as well as salt and pepper. 

Let the marinara sauce cool and thicken a bit and enjoy the flavor bomb exploding in your mouth as the juice from the sauce and the deli chicken mix in perfect harmony. 

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich


14 Substitutes for Marinara Sauce

Olives and Sour Cream 

Olive and sour cream is a delightfully refreshing combination capturing the hearts of many with its cheerfulness, zest, zing, and slight edge. All you need to do is blend the olives and mix them with sour cream. 

The olive brine will react with the sour cream thinning its consistency and turning it into a perfectly balanced mixture you can smear on your sandwich buns and enjoy the fresh and meaty flavors. 

Best Sauce for Chicken Salad Sandwich

Having some leftover chicken salad in your fridge is very probable, especially during the holiday season. So, instead of having it in the same form and shape until you wipe it out, you can mix things up by making a chicken salad sandwich enriched with some of the sauce ideas below. 


Since chicken salad has pickles inside, they pretty much define the taste and set the tone, so you need a sauce that carries on with the same mood, adding a little character of its own. Enter tartar sauce. 

Made with mayo and grated pickles, seasoned with pepper and maybe some powdered garlic, this sauce is a classic, and for a good reason. It is creamy, rich, juicy, and very delicious. Your chicken salad will go from rich to decadent with this sauce creating a little piece of heaven from your sandwich.


The tzatziki sauce proves what herbs, Greek yogurt, and a little love can do. Mix the Greek yogurt with herbs of your choosing, thyme and dill being among them, and enjoy the playful flavors fighting for a brief moment in the spotlight. 

The tzatziki sauce will make your chicken salad sandwich taste somewhat Mediterranean, filling your mouth with creamy textures, crunchy surprises, and creamy decadence. 


What Sauce Goes with Turkey Sandwich? 11 Perfect Combos

Sour Cream and Mayo

A simple mixture such as sour cream and mayo could be just what you need to enhance and improve your chicken salad sandwich. Mix the mayo and sour cream together, and your sauce is ready. 

This gentle sauce will add a certain softness to your chicken salad sandwich, toning down the tang of the pickles while enhancing the taste of the chicken salad. 

Best Sauce for Spicy Chicken Sandwich

A spicy chicken sandwich is zesty, hot, and full of flavor. Depending on your preference, mixing spices, flavors, aromas, and styles can vary from mildly to heavily spiced. When adding sauce to a spicy chicken sandwich, you need to go softly and be as gentle as possible so as not to overwhelm the flavor. 

The following sauces might help you. 

Sour Cream and Herbs

Yes, it is as simple as it sounds. When enriching your spicy chicken sandwich, nothing more than sour cream and herbs can make all the difference in the world. The gentle creaminess of the sour cream will help tone down any excessively expressive flavors, while the herbs will add some sweetness to the sandwich. 

Sweet Tomato Sauce 

There is something about spiciness and sweetness that makes them go excellently together. Much like marinara sauce, sweet tomato sauce is marinara with sugar. The sugar will sweeten up the sauce, which will then sweeten up the spicy chicken sandwich. 

All you need to do is blend and simmer the tomatoes with hot oil and add a spoonful of brown sugar. The sugar will additionally thicken the sweet tomato sauce, making it the perfect addition to your spicy chicken sandwich. 

Honey Beer 

This mixture can be both a sauce and a glaze, so keep it in mind next time you want to glaze chicken. This sauce requires some cooking, so it is worth the effort if you have the time and energy. 

First, add oil to a pan and heat it up. Add the honey and some soy sauce, and let the honey melt thoroughly. Next, add thyme, and lastly, add the beer. Mix everything and let it simmer for a minute. 

Take the pan off the stove and let the sauce cool down. Enjoy. 

Best Sauce for Shredded Chicken Sandwich

A shredded chicken sandwich can be made with either grilled, fried, or spicy chicken, so depending on the chicken, any of the sauces above will do. However, the three sauces below will give you a firm starting point. 


This sauce is an excellent addition to a shredded chicken sandwich and is made with butter, heavy cream, parmesan, Italian seasoning, and minced garlic. Melt the butter in a pan and add the minced garlic and cream, mixing until they homogenize. 

Let them simmer for a minute or two, and then add the parmesan. Mix everything well and let the sauce cool. Smear a thick layer of this delicacy on your sandwich buns and enjoy the deliciousness this sandwich offers you. 

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich

Cream of Champignon 

Although cream of champignon is technically a creamy soup, adding less water will thicken it and become a proper sauce. To enrich this sauce, you can also add cooking cream to create a creamy consistency. The expressive mushroom flavor will pair perfectly with your shredded chicken sandwich. 

Curry Sauce  

To make the curry sauce, chop onions and garlic and sizzle them in butter until they soften. Next, stir the curry powder and cooking cream in the pot. When you notice that the consistency is smooth and creamy, that is your sign that the sauce is ready. 

Smear it on your sandwich buns and enjoy your curry-flavored shredded chicken sandwich.

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich

Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich

Author: Laura Bais
The Carolina BBQ sauce is one of the best sauces for grilled chicken sandwiches made with hot sauce, red pepper, spices, and vinegar.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Course Main Course, Side Dish
Cuisine American
Servings 1 person
Calories 78 kcal


  • ½ cup apple cider vinegar
  • 1 tbsp dark brown sugar
  • ½ tbsp hot sauce
  • ¼ tsp cayenne pepper
  • ½ tsp red pepper flakes
  • ½ tsp pepper ground
  • ½ tsp salt


  • All you need to do is mix the ingredients, adding the vinegar last and the hot sauce first.
  • Dosage the spices so that none of them dominates by adding them slowly and trying the sauce frequently. 
  • It works best when made ahead of time, so it has enough time to set in the fridge. 


Serving: 1personCalories: 78kcalCarbohydrates: 14gProtein: 0.3gFat: 0.3gSaturated Fat: 0.1gPolyunsaturated Fat: 0.1gMonounsaturated Fat: 0.1gSodium: 1361mgPotassium: 156mgFiber: 1gSugar: 12gVitamin A: 521IUVitamin C: 5mgCalcium: 28mgIron: 1mg
Keyword Barbeque Sauce, Best Sauce for Chicken Sandwich
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments