Looking for the Best Pumpkin Pie in Chicago? Start With These Local Bakeries
Pumpkin pie is the dessert most people expect on the Thanksgiving table. If you don’t have time to bake one, Chicago’s bakeries are ready to help, from century-old family shops to small neighborhood cafés.
Many bakeries are already taking orders for Thursday, Nov. 26, and some deadlines are only days away. Here’s where to find a great pumpkin pie.
Floriole Café & Bakery
Floriole started as a stand at the Green City Market before opening its Lincoln Park café at 1220 W. Webster Ave. in 2010. Owner Sandra Holl is known for her flaky crusts.
This year’s lineup includes a 9-inch honey caramel pumpkin pie for $64, along with apple crumble and savory options like turkey pot pie. Order online by Sunday, Nov. 22, and pick up between Nov. 23 and 25.
Roeser’s Bakery
Roeser’s has been family-owned since 1931 and is a Humboldt Park institution. For Thanksgiving, it offers about a dozen pies, including classic pumpkin and pumpkin cheese.
Other choices include Dutch apple, pecan and chocolate banana. Order online or call 773-489-6900. Pies are also sold in the store at 3216 W. North Ave. while they last.
Sweet Mandy B’s
This cheerful bakery has locations in Lincoln Park and Streeterville. Its pumpkin pie costs $32, and other choices include apple streusel, pecan and apple cherry streusel.
Preorders run Nov. 22 through 26, and both bakeries are open on Thanksgiving morning. That makes Sweet Mandy B’s a good bet if you’re running late.
Beatrix Market
Want something a little fancier than a classic pumpkin pie? Beatrix Market’s Pumpkin Pecan Chiffon pie costs $55. It also offers an Oh My! Caramel pie and a gluten-free chocolate cake.
The deadline for market locations is Nov. 20, so order right away. Pickup runs Nov. 24 from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. and Nov. 25 from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits in Logan Square, at 2051 N. California Ave., is a good stop if you need both a dessert and a savory dish. Its holiday menu has sweet pies from pumpkin to chocolate pecan, plus pot pies.
Its pies tend to sell out before Thanksgiving, so check availability and order as soon as you can.
