7 Chicago Bakeries and Shops Taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders in 2026

chicago thanksgiving piePin
Images via Canva
Share on:

Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, and the best pie orders close well before the holiday. One deadline lands tomorrow.

These seven shops have posted their 2026 details. Prices and dates are the latest published figures, so check the shop before you pay.

Brown Sugar Bakery

This Chatham bakery has a Thanksgiving special that pairs a two-layer caramel cake with a nine-inch sweet potato pie for $64.98. Pre-orders close Sunday, Nov. 15, so the deadline is tomorrow.

Pickup is at the shop at 328 E. 75th St. from Nov. 22 through Nov. 25. A second pickup point at 7637 S. Western Ave. is open Nov. 23 and 24. Pickup is local only, and you choose your time when you order.

The caramel cake is the shop’s headline item. The Infatuation calls it the real standout, with light, open crumb layers.

Beatrix Market

Beatrix sells three desserts for Thanksgiving. They are the Pumpkin Pecan Chiffon at $55, the Oh My! Caramel at $50, and a gluten-free chocolate cake at $55, plus tax.

Orders at the market locations are due by Nov. 20. Pickup or delivery is Nov. 24 from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. and Nov. 25 from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.

The Pumpkin Pecan Chiffon and the Oh My! Caramel are the two pies on the list. Beatrix’s restaurant locations take pie orders with 48 hours of notice.

Alliance Bakery

Alliance Bakery is taking Thanksgiving pie orders with a deadline of midnight on Tuesday, Nov. 24. Pies are limited at both locations.

The page doesn’t list flavors or prices. Use the order form linked on the site, or call (773) 278-0366.

The Wicker Park shop is known for French-inspired pastries and cakes. The Infatuation singles out its vegan peanut butter chocolate cupcake, so ask what else is baked that week.

Sweet Mandy B’s

Sweet Mandy B’s has four pies this year: apple streusel at $30, pumpkin at $32, pecan at $36, and apple cherry streusel at $32. The apple cherry is only in Lincoln Park.

Pre-orders run Nov. 22 through Nov. 26. Both bakeries are open Thanksgiving morning.

The bakery is known for old-fashioned desserts in Lincoln Park and Streeterville. Apple streusel is the first pie on the list.

Hoosier Mama Pie Company

Hoosier Mama is a pie shop that locals call a West Town favorite. Its order page lists Thanksgiving ordering for Tuesday, Nov. 24 through Thursday, Nov. 26.

The page says whole pies need a two-day lead time. It links to the Evanston ordering page, and the flavors aren’t posted yet.

Confirm the dates, flavors, and the pickup location directly on the shop’s site before you order.

The Original Rainbow Cone

If your table has ice cream fans, Rainbow Cone sells ice cream pies. They’re $26.99 for a whole pie and $4.99 for a single slice.

The shop’s signature is five layers: chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House (vanilla with walnuts and cherries), pistachio, and orange sherbet. The Infatuation says to get it in a dish rather than a cone.

Ask the shop which pie flavors are available before you order.

Moody’s Cake & Wine

Moody’s in Avondale is taking take-and-bake and pie orders for Thanksgiving. Pre-orders close online on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 5 p.m.

Pickup is Tuesday, Nov. 24 and Wednesday, Nov. 25. Prices aren’t listed.

Check the shop’s online order page for the current pie flavors.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted