Zagnut vs. Butterfinger: Differences & Which Is Better?

zagnut vs butterfinger
Share on:

If you are a fan of peanut butter, then you probably enjoy snacks and treats that include this flavor in this content. Therefore, you have probably had the chance to try both Zagnut and Butterfinger, and you have probably noticed that they contain similar ingredients, i.e., they taste similarly. But, the question is which chocolate is better, and should you go for Zagnut or Butterfinger? 

Both Zagnut and Butterfinger contain grounded peanuts and peanut butter in their texture; therefore, they give a similar taste. However, their outer texture is not the same since Zagnut is covered by a toasted coconut layer, while Butterfinger includes chocolate as the main coverage.

To better understand the differences that exist between Zagnut and Butterfinger, you have to compare their ingredients, appearance, and nutritional facts. Luckily, I have done that for you, so once you read this article you will be able to determine which one will be more suitable for your taste or needs. Sometimes, it is really difficult to choose the appropriate snack. Therefore, a little bit of research will ease up your decision. 

What Is the Difference Between Zagnut And Butterfinger? 

Even though these two snacks have quite similar tastes and quite similar ingredients, many people confuse them for the same peanut butter bar. However, some significant differences make them distinct, thus the reason why some people prefer one more than the other. Below, I have made a comparison regarding nutrition, ingredients, as well as appearance, so you will obtain a clearer idea of how different these snacks actually are.


Most of the ingredients included in both Zagnut and Butterfinger are the same; however, those that are unique for one or the other make a huge difference in taste and appearance. For instance, both Zagnut and Butterfinger contain peanut butter as their main ingredient, yet their cover layer is quite different. Namely, Zagnut is covered with a layer of toasted coconut, while Butterfinger is covered with chocolate on the top. 

The other ingredients are the same in both snacks. In other words, the bases of these bars consist of peanut butter, peanuts, corn syrup, sugar, milk, and other artificial flavors. 

Appearance And Taste 

On the one hand, Zagnut is based on peanut butter and peanuts. It is crispy and crunchy, and due to the absence of chocolate, it can be said that it is a bit salty. There is a unique balance between sweetness and saltiness, which makes Zagnut characterized by a special taste.

The coating of Zagnut is actually what makes this bar visibly different from Butterfinger. The toasted coconut layer gives this bar a totally different appearance, although its center is the same as Butterfinger. Therefore, when you taste both treats, you might not notice such a big difference, but the appearance is quite distinct. 

On the other hand, Butterfinger has a smooth surface since a layer of chocolate covers it, and it is sweeter than Zagnut. Butterfinger does not have a tiny bit of saltiness, so people who pay close attention to the taste would be able to spot the difference immediately. So, when it comes to taste, you will need to determine whether you prefer something simply sweet or something that includes salty bits. 

Nutrition Facts 

If you compare these bars in regular sizes, you will notice that Zagnut contains fewer calories than Butterfinger. In addition, Butterfinger includes a higher amount of fat and a higher number of carbs in the bar. Also, Zagnut has a fewer percentage of sodium in comparison to Butterfinger, although we are talking about slight differences here. [1] [2]

However, when you look at the beneficial nutrition information, it could be seen that Butterfinger is a better source of protein than Zagnut.

In other words, the nutrition facts are not extremely different, but if you care about the beneficial features of candy bars, then Butterfinger might be the better option here. 

Butterfinger vs. Zagnut: Which One to Choose? 

If you read the information above, you would see that the biggest difference is in the cover layers of the bars. There are significant differences neither in the ingredients nor in the nutrition facts. This means that these two candy bars are closely related, although they come from a different manufacturer. 

However, if you prefer some saltiness in your candy bar, then Butterfinger might be the better option.

Zagnut provides a quite unique taste, and this is not commonly found in other snack bars. Therefore, if you are a fan of a crunchy peanut butter base covered with a coconut layer, choose Zagnut.

On the other hand, if you are looking for something sweeter, common for a candy bar, then Butterfinger would be your ideal option.

Is Zagnut a Real Candy Bar? 

Although it has an odd texture and taste, which is not really common for candy bars, Zagnut is still a real candy bar that contains sweet ingredients and is made in the same proportions. Some people might believe that this is not actually candy, but Zagnut contains a significant amount of sugar; therefore, you should not be bothered very much by the tiny bits of saltiness included in it. 

Because Zagnut and Butterfinger have the same base, they might be taken as the same candy bars. However, the layers that cover them make a significant difference, so you should not be confused by these two distinct types of snacks.