Thanksgiving Pie Recipes for Your Holiday Dinners

Looking for Thanksgiving pie recipes to finish off your holiday feast? A Thanksgiving table doesn’t look finished without pies, whether it’s a classic pie flavor or something with a twist. So, I’ve made this list of the most amazing and delicious Thanksgiving pie recipes that you should try this Thanksgiving!

No matter what type of pie you like, I’m sure you’ll find something you love here! 

Pin

Mexican Apple Pie

This pie comes with an apple and cinnamon combo that just screams Thanksgiving, and it’s one of my personal favorites! It’s super simple to make, and the taste is absolutely out-of-this-world.  I’m sure it will quickly become one of your favorites too!

Cinnamon Sugar Apple Butter Pie

The cinnamon sugar toppings on this pie are just a chef’s kiss, and I love that the crust is gluten-free! The apple butter filling creates that Thanksgiving cozy flavor that pairs perfectly with the sweet and crackly cinnamon sugar layer on top! 

Vegan Pecan Pie Cookies

Want a twist on your usual pies? Try these pecan pie cookies! They are vegan and deliciously chewy, with a gooey homemade pecan filling that will have you reaching for more. I’m 100% sure that these pie cookies will be a hit! 

Buttermilk Pumpkin Streusel Pie

This pie just looks absolutely delicious! The tang of buttermilk combined with the pumpkin filling and crunchy streusel topping has me already sold. I can’t wait to try this myself at my next gathering!

Classic Pumpkin Pie

Let’s go back to our roots with this classic pumpkin pie recipe that you can easily add to your Thanksgiving table! You could never go wrong with a pumpkin pie! This recipe comes with a pumpkin-packed filling that captures all those beloved fall flavors! 

Eggnog Pie

For eggnog lovers out there, you should definitely try this pie! What I like most is the absolutely stunning decoration—I’m in love. The spiced gingerbread crust perfectly matches the creamy eggnog filling, making it a real treat! 

Apple and Cranberry Hand Pies

These apple and cranberry hand pies are perfect for a little treat at your Thanksgiving celebration! I just know these will be a crowd favorite, combining the best of fall flavors in a delicious pie. They’re a charming and tasty addition to any holiday spread!

Gooey Chocolate Chip Cookie Pumpkin Pie

This gooey chocolate chip cookie pumpkin pie is the perfect Thanksgiving treat! I really love the gooey texture that perfectly matches the crisp pie crust. Swirled with pumpkin butter and extra chocolate, it’s definitely a must-try! 

Easy Gingerbread Cream Pie

If you’re feeling the Christmas vibes already check out this gingerbread cream pie for your Thanksgiving dinner! The decoration is one of the cutest I’ve seen and delicious too. The creamy filling, packed with gingerbread flavor, pairs perfectly with the soft, mellow homemade whipped cream! 

Apple Crumble Pie

If you know me, you’ll know I’m a huge fan of crunchy textures! This apple crumble pie is just the best, with a buttery crumble that perfectly matches the cinnamon-spiced apple slices. The apples will absolutely give you those Thanksgiving vibes! 

Deep-Dish Cranberry Pie

Another classic Thanksgiving ingredient is cranberries, and I’m absolutely in awe of this pie! Just look at that presentation—it looks so good and tastes even better. It’s a stunning addition to your holiday table! 

Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie

I just can’t get enough of cinnamon and apple combos! This cinnamon roll apple pie has completely stolen my heart with its gorgeous presentation and flavor. It’s definitely a must-have for Thanksgiving—both for its looks and taste!

Apple Pie Pops

If you’re looking for something new, with smaller servings that are still incredibly tasty, then these pie pops are for you! They’re so cute and perfect for enjoying apple pie on the go! I also love how you can drizzle them with caramel sauce or just enjoy them as they are! 

Mini Pumpkin Hand Pies

Since small pies have been catching my eye lately (they’re just so cute!), here’s another hand pie recipe that I’m excited about! Look how stunning they are, and they taste delicious too. These mini pumpkin hand pies are perfect!

Dutch Tart Cherry Pie 

If you’re looking for new flavors this Thanksgiving, definitely give this tart cherry pie a try! The crunchy topping is absolutely delightful, and the filling is perfectly sweet. I promise you, it’s a delicious change from the usual pies!

Pretzel-Crusted Vegan Pumpkin Pie

Using a pretzel crust for this pie is such a smart and tasty twist! I can only imagine how crunchy and delicious it will be—just wow! As you know, I love anything crunchy! It’s a unique take on classic pumpkin pie.

Warm Apple Tart

I have no words—I’m just in love with this apple tart! The presentation is absolutely heavenly, and it’s so easy to make. It’s a perfect blend of simplicity and elegance that will wow anyone who tries it! 

Classic Pumpkin Pie With A Leafy Crust

The look of this pie already screams Thanksgiving! Those leafy crust decorations are so inviting and make me want to add this to my Thanksgiving table – it’s like they are calling me! This recipe is not just delicious; it’s also a charming addition to your holiday menu. 

Oatmeal Creme Apple Pie

For oatmeal lovers out there, this pie is perfect for you! It’s an exciting addition to your holiday meal, with its delicious oatmeal crust and creamy apple filling. This is a 100% crowd-pleaser! I know that a lot of people will keep coming back to it (just like me!). 

Apple Cranberry Pie

Here’s another delightful apple and cranberry pie combo that I just can’t get enough of! The presentation is absolutely beautiful and looks as tasty as it sounds. With a hint of orange and spices, this pie perfectly combines traditional flavors! 

Pumpkin Ruffled Milk Pie

OMG, did someone mention ruffled milk pie? This pumpkin version is 100% textural heaven, with crispy ruffled layers blending perfectly with a custardy, spiced flavor. The textures and flavors come together in a truly delightful way!

Old Fashioned Blueberry Pie with Fresh Berries

Of course, let’s not forget the classic blueberry pie! This one, made with fresh berries, is an ideal addition to your holiday table. The golden brown, flaky crust pairs perfectly with the sweet, juicy filling—it’s a timeless treat everyone will love!

Pumpkin Pie Brûlée With Bourbon Vanilla Whipped Cream

I know I’m not the only one who believes that any simple whipped cream automatically improves the meal! This pumpkin pie brûlée with bourbon vanilla whipped cream is just perfect, with its crunchy caramel top and silky spiced filling. Plus, the autumn leaf-shaped crust adds a charming touch!

Classic Strawberry Pie

I know strawberries aren’t the usual Thanksgiving ingredient, but hey! For me, they’re always in season and a delightful treat! So, here’s a classic strawberry pie recipe that’s perfect for adding a fresh twist to your Thanksgiving table! 

Fresh Blackberry Hand Pies

Here’s another hand pie for you—I’m clearly a big fan of these little pies! This one features a classic fresh blackberry filling that’s juicy and tangy, with just a hint of lemon! It’s such a perfect single-serve treat that’s both portable and delicious!

Apple and Browned Butter Tart

Just look at those apples! This classic tart, with its browned butter and apple filling, is incredibly mouthwatering—seeing it actually made me feel hungry and eager to make it ASAP. It’s a delicious pie that combines classic rich flavors with a tasty presentation!

Old-Fashioned Apple Pie

It’s practically illegal to end this list without including a classic apple pie! You can never go wrong with this timeless favorite—it never gets old and is super easy to make. With its flaky crust and perfectly spiced filling, it’s a must-have for any holiday spread!

So much love and thanks to the original creators of these delicious Thanksgiving pie recipes! I am in love with all of them!