New York City’s Italian Grocery Stores and Delis: Where to Find the Classics
Thanksgiving is this Thursday, and in plenty of New York households, the turkey shares the table with lasagna, stuffed artichokes or a platter of soppressata. A few weeks later comes Christmas Eve and the Feast of the Seven Fishes. That puts the city’s Italian grocers and delis squarely in their busy season.
Some of these shops have been slicing, curing and stretching mozzarella for more than a century. Here’s where to find the classics, from Manhattan to the Bronx and Brooklyn.
Di Palo’s Fine Foods, Little Italy
At the corner of Grand and Mott streets, Di Palo’s is one of the last links to the Little Italy of old. The family’s story starts with Lou Di Palo’s great-grandfather Savino, who arrived from southern Italy in 1903 and opened a dairy seven years later. In 1925, Lou’s grandparents opened the shop that still stands today, and Di Palo’s marked its 100th anniversary last year.
Little Italy once had about 30 of these old dairies, called latterie. Only Di Palo’s remains. The mozzarella is still made by hand daily, and it shares the counter with a huge selection of imported cheeses, cured meats, olive oils and pastas.
Expect to wait, especially around the holidays. Part of the appeal is that Lou Di Palo or a family member will often explain what you’re buying. As he put it in his book, you are the only customer once your turn comes.
Faicco’s Italian Specialties, West Village
Faicco’s has been a deli staple since 1900. It moved to 260 Bleecker St. in the 1940s and is now run by the fourth generation of the family.
The shelves and cases hold house-made sausages, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, hot peppers and olives. There are also prepared dishes like lasagna and eggplant parm, which come in handy for anyone hosting this week. The Infatuation says Faicco’s makes what may be NYC’s top chicken cutlet sandwich.
Raffetto’s, Greenwich Village
Just down the street at 144 W. Houston St., Raffetto’s has been making pasta since Marcello Raffetto opened the shop in 1906. Fresh sheets are still cut to the width you ask for on a manual machine the shop has used since 1916.
Raffetto’s makes about 50 kinds of pasta, plus ravioli and sauces. If you’ve had great “homemade” pasta at an Italian restaurant in the city, it may have come from here, since the shop quietly supplies dozens of restaurants.
Arthur Avenue, the Bronx
Many New Yorkers will tell you the city’s real Little Italy is in the Belmont section of the Bronx. Plan for a few hours, because the shops are close together and worth taking slowly.
Start at Teitel Brothers, a grocery opened in 1915 by two Jewish brothers from Austria. A mosaic Star of David has marked the doorway since the Depression. Inside are barrels of olives, wheels of Parmigiano-Reggiano, canned tomatoes, imported oils and hard-to-find items like cardoons.
Next door, Calabria Pork Store is known for its “sausage chandelier,” hundreds of dried sausages hanging from the ceiling. It is one of the few shops in New York with a permit to cure its own meat. Fans recommend the extra-hot soppressata.
Arthur Avenue Retail Market
Mayor Fiorello La Guardia opened the indoor market in 1940 to clear the avenue of pushcarts. Today it houses butchers, produce sellers, a pasta importer and the Bronx Beer Hall.
The best-known stall is Mike’s Deli, run by David Greco. He beat Bobby Flay on “Throwdown” with his eggplant Parmesan. Get a prosciutto and mozzarella hero, or take home some smoked mozzarella.
Brooklyn Classics
In Carroll Gardens, Caputo’s Fine Foods has been a neighborhood staple since 1973. Shoppers come for homemade ricotta and mozzarella, hand-cured meats and frozen handmade ravioli. Tasting Table lists it among the city’s top Italian delis.
Nearby in Red Hook, Defonte’s Sandwich Shop at 379 Columbia St. is a longtime favorite for giant heroes. It has been around so long that Nick Defonte reportedly paid $100 for the place.
Tips Before You Go
The week of Thanksgiving and the weeks before Christmas bring the longest lines of the year. Go early on a weekday if you can.
Some of these shops close or keep shorter hours on holidays, so check before heading out on Wednesday or Thursday. If you need a large order of fresh pasta, mozzarella or prepared trays, call ahead.
