How to Reheat Domino’s Pizza? [Best Tips]

How to Reheat Domino's Pizza

There’s nothing sadder than watching a great pizza go to waste. Sadly, it is often the case when the eye is greedy, and you get more than you can handle. Therefore you need a backup option for that leftover Domino’s pizza. So, how to reheat Domino’s pizza? 

You can reheat Domino’s pizza using the oven, microwave, toaster, or air fryer. There are more and less effective methods, and it doesn’t hurt to know something about them before applying them.

Knowing how to reheat Domino’s pizza is gold-worthy knowledge that can save you a lot of grief. Not reheating your Domino’s pizza would mean having it cold and week-tasting or letting it go to waste. Since none of these options are good, in the following paragraphs, I will explain the methods of reheating Domino’s leftover pizza so you can enjoy every piece.

How to Reheat Domino’s Pizza in the Microwave?

Reheating Domino’s pizza in the microwave is probably the easiest way to reheat your pizza, but it is not the wisest thing to do. The microwave tends to add a significant amount of moisture to the dishes you reheat, which is not bad, but it doesn’t work on all foods. 

Even though the pizza topping will heat up, release the juices in the dough, and the cheese will melt delightfully, you will still be having wet pizza. The topping will probably slide off the dough, as it will be wet and won’t hold well. 

Therefore, avoid the microwave method if you have time and aren’t in a rush. Usually, you cover them with a cotton towel to prevent the microwave moisture and your meal. That is not an option with Domino’s pizza.

The only thing you will do is stain the cotton towel and wipe off the pizza sauce. 

How to Reheat Domino’s Pizza in the Oven?

The oven is a great way to reheat your Domino’s pizza leftovers. It heats the pizza evenly, and it produces excellent results. You need to preheat the oven at 175 °C/350 °F for 10 minutes before putting the pizza inside. 

Grease up a piece of parchment paper and place it on a baking tray. Place the pizza on the tray and put it in the oven. Bake at the same temperature for the first five minutes and increase it by 10 degrees for the next five minutes. 

After the second five minutes, check the pizza and prolong its baking time, if necessary, by five more minutes, at the temperature you set previously. 

The pizza will come out juicy with nice crispy edges, almost as good as freshly made. 

Can You Put Domino’s Pizza Box in the Oven?

The Domino’s pizza box is made of cardboard, which is a flammable material, and it is, therefore, not safe to put it in the oven. The maximum temperature it can withhold is about 400 °F/200 °C. You may think that setting the temperature under the allowed limit would be safe, but it won’t. 

You should never try your luck with safety, so never place the Pizza Hut Box in the oven. 

How to Reheat Domino's Pizza

How to Reheat Domino’s Pizza in an Air Fryer?

The air fryer is another great way to reheat your Domino’s pizza. It will slowly and gradually reheat your pizza, leaving it juicy where it needs to be juicy and crispy where it needs to be crispy. 

Place the pizza on greased parchment paper and put it in the air fryer. Set the temperature to medium and start cooking. The process shouldn’t take more than 10 minutes, but check the pizza after the initial five minutes in the air fryer. 

The circulating air inside the air fryer will penetrate the pizza, heating it up and reviving its flavors. 

How to Reheat Domino’s Pizza in the Toaster Oven?

Like the microwave, the toaster oven should probably be your last resort. It dehydrates the pizza, leaving the cheese hard and stuck to the dough instead of melting it. The pizza sauces will also significantly diminish in flavor, and the crust will be overly crispy. 

If you like your pizza that way, go for this method without thinking twice, but if you don’t, the toaster oven shouldn’t be your first choice.  

Reheat the Domino’s pizza at medium temperature, or even a bit lower, as the air inside the toaster oven is pretty compressed and dry. Cook for five minutes and check the pizza. If it is good enough for you, take it out, and if you want it warmer, keep going for not more than five minutes. 

If the pizza turns out dry, pour some sauce on it to add moisture, but don’t expect miracles. 

Can You Reheat Domino’s Pizza the Next Day?

Domino’s pizzas are known for their juiciness and greasiness, meaning that they contain perishables that are not safe to eat after a while. On the other hand, cooked perishables, primarily oven-baked ones, are known to remain safe longer.

Therefore, I would say that you can reheat Domino’s pizza the next day, but you need to increase the temperature of the appliance you use and the time you reheat the pizza. However, that would mean having a dryer pizza with fewer juices and a crunchy crust. 

So, in cases like these, I would recommend freezing the pizza rather than reheating it, as it would be juicier when you reheat it after thawing. 

What Is the Best Way to Reheat Domino’s Pizza?

The best way to reheat Domino’s pizza would be the oven. Since you bake the pizza in an oven, reviving it is the most natural way. The oven heats the pizza evenly from all sides and leaves it fresh and juicy. 

You don’t have to add anything to the Domino’s pizza before or after oven-heating it. The oven will resurface its juices and remelt the cheese toppings. Your pizza will be nearly as tasty as freshly made. 

  • Laura is the owner of Julie's Cafe Bakery. She started this blog with her grandma Julie who introduced her to the amazing world of cooking. She likes to experiment with different flavors, and her favorite flavors combo is chicken with coconut milk, curry and peanuts!