Hosting Thanksgiving in Boston? Don’t Leave the Store Without These Local Staples

thanksgiving dinner in bostonPin
Images via Canva
Share on:

Boston has a special claim on Thanksgiving. The holiday’s roots run through Massachusetts, and plenty of local families still cook dishes that go back generations.

If you’re hosting this year, the usual turkey and potatoes are only the beginning. Here’s what to add to your Boston-area shopping list.

A Box of Bell’s Seasoning

For many New England cooks, stuffing isn’t stuffing without the little yellow box. Boston inventor William G. Bell created the salt-free herb blend in 1867, and the recipe has barely changed since.

Bell’s had a rough patch recently. In 2024, its stuffing mix disappeared from store shelves after the previous owner ran into financial trouble. New owners have since brought the line back, including the traditional stuffing mix.

Grab a box early. Plenty of other locals will be shopping for it, too.

Massachusetts Cranberries

Cranberry sauce has extra meaning in the Bay State. Commercial cranberry growing began on Cape Cod in 1816, and Massachusetts is now the country’s second-largest producer after Wisconsin.

Governor Maura Healey even proclaimed October as Massachusetts Cranberry Month this year. With the harvest wrapped up in early November, fresh local berries should be easy to find. Look for bags from Massachusetts growers.

Parker House Rolls

Boston gave the country one of its favorite dinner rolls. Parker House rolls were created at Boston’s Parker House hotel in the late 1800s.

The hotel, now the Omni Parker House, still serves them. You can bake your own with flour, yeast, milk and lots of butter, or pick some up from a local bakery.

Squash for the Pie

Pumpkin pie is everywhere, but many New England families bake squash pie instead. Blue Hubbard squash is a classic choice, with light blue skin and orange flesh.

The big squashes can be a lot to handle. Many supermarkets sell them cut into smaller chunks, and farm stands carry whole ones. If you’d rather skip the chopping, look for canned One-Pie squash.

Cornmeal and Molasses for Indian Pudding

Indian pudding is one of the region’s oldest desserts. Early colonists made it with cornmeal, which they called “Indian meal,” in place of flour.

The slow-baked pudding became famous at Boston’s longtime Durgin-Park restaurant, where it was served warm with vanilla ice cream. To make it at home, you’ll need cornmeal, molasses, milk, ginger and cinnamon, plus a carton of vanilla ice cream.

A Boston Cream Pie

Boston cream pie is the official state dessert of Massachusetts, and it also comes from the Parker House. The custard-filled cake with chocolate frosting has been served at the hotel’s restaurant since the hotel opened in 1856.

You can bake one from scratch or buy one from a local bakery. The Omni Parker House also ships its original pie anywhere in the country, which makes it an easy gift for Boston transplants missing home.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted