Eater’s 2026 Dishes of the Year Include Pickled Walleye Cheeks, a Crab Callaloo Dip, and a Grown-Up Jell-O
Eater’s editors ate at hundreds of restaurants across the country this year, but a handful of plates stuck with them long after the meal ended. For 2026, the food site added a new national award category to honor those dishes.
The five winners range from a perfectly executed roast chicken, this year’s most popular entrée, to a fish dish that gives Midwesterners a new way to enjoy a familiar catch. Here’s what made the cut.
Puffed Grain Toast at All Well, Chicago
This one is easy to overlook. At All Well in Chicago’s West Loop, a slice of puffed grain toast topped with honey-sweetened buckwheat butter arrives as a side to a pasta stuffed with Délice de Bourgogne cheese in chicken broth.
The restaurant comes from Larry Feldmeier and Noah Sandoval, both alumni of Chicago’s two-Michelin-star Oriole. The only way to try the toast is through the $145 five-course tasting menu. Eater said its gentle sweetness balances the rich meal and works almost like a dessert in the middle of dinner.
Island Curry Crab and Callaloo Dip at Dougla Kitchen, Oklahoma City
Chef Andrew Black draws on his Indo-Jamaican upbringing at Dougla Kitchen. The winning dish is a callaloo dip loaded with hand-picked crab and curry spices, served with crisp taro chips.
Eater said a single scoop captures the spirit of Caribbean home cooking. Black is a James Beard Award winner, and Dougla was one of the most anticipated openings of 2026.
Roast Chicken and Caesar Panzanella at Henrietta, Los Angeles
Roast chicken was everywhere in 2026, and Eater called Henrietta’s the best of the bunch. The half chicken has a smoky char and comes with a scorched lemon.
On the side is a Caesar panzanella packed with chicory and topped with Parmesan, made with bread from neighboring Clark Street Bakery. Eater praised the dish for being both precise and nostalgic. It also won Dish of the Year in Los Angeles.
Cantaloupe and Verjus Terrine at Junior, Nashville
On paper, this dessert sounds unusual. Cantaloupe is suspended in verjus gelatin, with cubes of cantaloupe dressed in turmeric oil and a cream steeped with chamomile.
It comes from chef Philip Krajeck and chef de cuisine Brian Mejia. The dish won over Eater’s Nashville scout, who said its layered textures and flavors make Jell-O feel sophisticated again.
Pickled Walleye Cheeks at Rosy, Cleveland
Walleye is a staple across the Midwest, but chef Vinnie Cimino found a fresh way to serve it at Rosy. Inspired by Jewish fish-pickling traditions, he pickles walleye cheeks and pairs them with seasonal vegetables pickled in lemon.
The dish costs $17 and is a smart example of reducing waste. The cheeks come from fish bought at Cleveland’s West Side Market, using a part that might otherwise be thrown away.
