Crescent Rolls vs. Puff Pastry: Differences & Which Is Better?

They are airy and light and have justifiably acquired the name of being among the most elegant pastries. Moreover, both crescent rolls and puff pastry handle filling excellently, but they are delicious plain and with no filling. As similar as they are, puff pastry and crescent rolls are different. So, what are the differences between crescent rolls and puff pastry? 

The yeast is the most significant determining factor making these two types of pastries different. Puff pastry is made of laminated dough with no yeast, while crescent rolls are made of laminated dough with yeast.

In the following paragraphs, I will explain the difference between puff pastry and crescent rolls in terms of making, quality, nutrition, and other specificities that make them unique. 

Crescent Rolls and Puff Pastry: Differences 

Both laminated, layered, buttery, and absolutely delicious, puff pastry and crescent rolls are incredibly flaky and mouth-watering pastries. Although their differences may seem subtle, they are significant enough to categorize these two as individual pastry types.

Preparation and Ingredients 

The most significant difference between these two pastries is the presence of yeast and the lamination process.

Puff pastry is made of laminated dough without yeast, while crescent rolls are made of yeasted dough that is also layered but not traditionally laminated in the same way as puff pastry.

• Puff pastry contains flour, water, salt, and a large amount of butter, which is layered through a process called laminating. After mixing the initial dough, butter is enclosed inside and folded multiple times, creating thin layers that rise when baked due to steam.
• Crescent rolls contain flour, water, butter, yeast, sugar, and sometimes eggs or milk. The dough is enriched and relies on yeast fermentation to rise, making it softer and slightly bread-like compared to puff pastry.

The technique used to make puff pastry involves placing a large slab of cold butter between layers of dough, folding, rolling, and chilling repeatedly. This creates hundreds of flaky layers that puff up when baked.

For crescent rolls, butter is typically cut into small pea-sized pieces or rubbed into the dough before rolling and folding, which creates a layered effect but is not as structured as puff pastry’s laminations. Crescent roll dough is then shaped into triangles and rolled into a crescent shape before baking.

While both require skill, puff pastry demands precise lamination for flakiness, while crescent rolls require careful kneading and proofing for a softer, airier texture.

Pin

Taste and Uses 

The word that best describes what crescent rolls and puff pastry taste like is buttery. Both types of dough are flaky and light, but they differ in texture:

• Puff pastry is extremely crispy and flaky, with delicate, visible layers that separate when baked.
• Crescent rolls are softer, slightly chewy, and more bread-like due to the yeast.

Both can be sweet or savory, depending on the filling or toppings used.

• Puff pastry is often used in turnovers, tarts, vol-au-vents, and pastries like Napoleons. It can be used for both desserts and appetizers.
• Crescent rolls are popular for dinner rolls, breakfast pastries, pigs in a blanket, or stuffed pastries with cheese or meats.

Even though puff pastry does not typically contain sugar, it can be layered with sweet ingredients before baking.

Nutrition 

Since the ingredients for puff pastry and crescent rolls are different, their nutritional values are not exactly the same. [1] [2]

• Puff pastry contains more butter, making it higher in fat.
• Crescent rolls contain sugar, eggs, and yeast, which add more carbohydrates and protein but slightly less fat.

The standard serving sizes of crescent rolls and puff pastry differ—typically, puff pastry is eaten in smaller amounts due to its richness, while crescent rolls are more substantial.

To say that puff pastry and crescent rolls are nutritious would be inaccurate, as they are primarily made of flour and fat. However, they do not contain harmful additives when made from scratch.

Popularity 

Crescent rolls and puff pastry are beloved worldwide, each with its own regional variations.

• Puff pastry is commonly used in French, European, and Middle Eastern pastries.
• Crescent rolls are especially popular in American baking, often seen in holiday meals, brunch spreads, and store-bought dough products like Pillsbury Crescent Rolls.

Both can be homemade or purchased pre-made in stores.

Crescent Rolls vs. Puff Pastry: Which Is Better? 

Crescent rolls and puff pastry cannot be compared in terms of quality—they serve different purposes. If a skillful baker has made them, then saying that one is better than the other is inaccurate.

• Puff pastry is typically not pre-filled, but it can be topped, filled to your taste, or used in layered desserts.
• Crescent rolls can be plain or filled before baking.

Your decision should be based on what you are making rather than one being “better” than the other.

Can You Substitute Crescent Rolls for Puff Pastry? 

Yes and no.

While both are laminated, they behave differently when baked:

• Puff pastry cannot be replaced with crescent roll dough because crescent rolls contain yeast, making them rise and become softer instead of flaky.
• Crescent rolls cannot be used as a direct substitute for puff pastry, as they lack the same ultra-thin, crispy layers.

However, in some cases, crescent roll dough can be used instead of puff pastry for certain recipes, especially in filled pastries or stuffed crescent roll recipes. Just expect a different texture and less flakiness.