Chicago’s 2026 Eater Awards Honor a Playful Bistro, a Guatemalan-Born Chef, and a Bucktown Bakery
Chicago’s dining scene had plenty to celebrate this year. Eater Chicago has announced its 2026 Eater Award winners, and the list includes a bistro reinventing the city’s classic flavors, a bakery with hour-long lines, and a chef connecting Mexican and Guatemalan cooking.
There’s also a nod to a growing trend: restaurants that come with their own bar attached. Here’s a look at the winners.
Best New Restaurant: Creepies
The name may be odd, but Creepies is serious about its food. Chefs David and Anna Posey, the couple behind Elske, opened this French bistro with a distinctly Chicago twist, with chef de cuisine Tayler Ploshehanski running the kitchen.
Steamed mussels come with Pernod and fennel giardiniera, and the tarte flambé is made tavern-style. There’s also Brie gougères, a roast chicken in a liver-enriched sauce, and a savory soft-serve built around baguette. Creepies also made Eater’s national Best New Restaurants list.
Chef of the Year: Cristian Orozco, Mazor
Cristian Orozco grew up in Pajapita, Guatemala, and cooked at Acadia, North Pond, and Tzuco before going out on his own. He opened Mazor in June 2026 and closed his Glen Ellyn restaurant, Five O Four, in October.
At Mazor, Orozco blends Mexican and Guatemalan traditions into polished dishes at friendly prices. A bluefin tuna tostada with ponzu and salsa macha costs just $9. The menu also includes tetelas with chorizo and cheese and a hibiscus flan with toasted white chocolate.
Best New Bakery: Bad Butter
Dan Koester was a head baker at Soho House Chicago before he was laid off in 2020. He built a big following with an online bakery, did a residency at the Emily Hotel, and opened his Bucktown shop in May.
Expect a long wait. Eater says the lines can run more than 60 minutes, so arrive early. Favorites include scallion furikake focaccia, twice-baked almond croissants, harissa monkey bread with labneh, and ginger plum cruffins. Bad Butter was also named one of the best new bakeries in the country.
Dish of the Year: Puffed Grain Toast at All Well
The winning dish is a small side at All Well in the West Loop. It’s a puffed grain toast with honeyed buckwheat butter that comes with a pasta stuffed with Délice de Bourgogne cheese in chicken broth.
The restaurant’s $145 five-course tasting menu comes from Larry Feldmeier and Noah Sandoval, both alumni of the two-Michelin-star Oriole. Sandoval is also a James Beard Award winner. Eater said the toast’s light sweetness balances the rich meal and works almost like dessert.
Best New Restaurant and Bar Combo: Crying Tiger and Kitty’s Cosmopolitan Club
Upstairs, Crying Tiger serves Southeast Asian food like peanut duck panang, crispy prawn toast, and clay pot lobster pad Thai. Don’t skip the tiger-shaped vanilla cake.
Downstairs, Kitty’s Cosmopolitan Club is a 1920s-style lounge pouring clarified whisky and Coke, Japanese Old Fashioneds, and gin martinis. Together, they make one of the city’s strongest dinner-and-drinks pairings.
Punch’s Best New Bar: Culebra
Hidden behind Lonesome Rose in Logan Square, Culebra celebrates Puerto Rican flavors. Owner Diego Garcia-Gonzalez grew up in the neighborhood and started bartending at 15. Daniel Maysonet Rivera of San Juan’s Jungle Bird helped create the menu.
Drinks include the Quesito Colada and the Culebra Manhattan, and the chicken thigh pinchito with salsa criolla is a good match. The bar’s team is entirely Latinx.
