Hosting Thanksgiving in Chicago? These Local Favorites Belong on Your Shopping List

thanksgiving dinner in chicagoPin
Images via Canva
Share on:

Chicago does Thanksgiving the way it does most things: with big appetites and plenty of neighborhood pride. The city’s immigrant communities have shaped its food for generations, and that shows on holiday tables.

If you’re hosting this year, here’s what to pick up beyond the turkey and cranberry sauce.

Pierogi and Kielbasa From a Polish Deli

Polish food has been part of Chicago since the city’s earliest days. The Chicago area is home to more than 700,000 Polish people, and Polish delis and restaurants are easy to find in the city and suburbs.

A tray of pierogi or a ring of smoked kielbasa makes an easy addition to the holiday spread. Pick some up at a local deli on Wednesday so you’re not cooking everything on Thursday.

Kolaczki for the Dessert Table

These buttery Polish cookies, filled with fruit or cheese, are a Chicago holiday classic. You don’t need to visit a specialty bakery, either. Kolaczki are sold in the bakery sections at Jewel and Mariano’s.

If you want to bake your own, add flour, cream cheese, butter and fruit filling to your list. The cookies freeze well, so you can make them ahead.

A Dozen Tamales

Tamales show up on plenty of Chicago holiday tables, especially in neighborhoods like Pilsen and Little Village. They make an easy appetizer while the turkey finishes roasting.

Popular spots get busy this time of year. Some shops sell out by lunchtime, so it’s smart to place your order early.

An Eli’s Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin pie is great, but Chicagoans have a hometown alternative. Eli’s Cheesecake debuted at the Taste of Chicago in 1980 and quickly became a local favorite.

Its seasonal pumpkin pie cheesecake combines both desserts in a vanilla crumb crust, topped with Chantilly cream and praline sprinkles. You can pick one up at Eli’s Cheesecake World on the city’s Northwest Side.

Frango Mints for the Host

If you’re a guest this year, a box of Frango mints makes a very Chicago thank-you gift. The chocolates became a beloved holiday tradition for many Chicagoans through Marshall Field’s.

The original candy kitchen is gone, but Macy’s still sells Frango mints in holiday tins.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted