Store-Bought Dinner Rolls That Keep Winning Taste Tests Ahead of Thanksgiving
Homemade dinner rolls are a labor of love, but they also mean hours of kneading and rising on the busiest cooking day of the year. Luckily, the bread aisle and freezer case have plenty of shortcuts that can fool even the pickiest relatives.
Food writers have spent the season tasting, toasting and buttering dozens of packaged rolls. These five keep coming out on top, and you can find them at grocery stores across the US.
King’s Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls
If there’s a default Thanksgiving roll in America, this is it. In a Mashed reader poll, King’s Hawaiian was the top pick for Thanksgiving with more than 38% of the vote. Pepperidge Farm and Sister Schubert’s trailed far behind.
Professionals agree. When Eat This, Not That! asked four bakers for their favorite store-bought option, all four chose King’s Hawaiian. They praised the rolls’ soft, fluffy texture and gentle sweetness.
The Daily Meal also ranked them second in its 10-brand test. It called them the sweet roll every copycat tries to imitate.
Sister Schubert’s Parker House Style Yeast Rolls
These freezer-aisle favorites have a loyal following in many family kitchens. Food Network staffers named them a Thanksgiving go-to, describing them as buttery, soft and easy to bake straight from frozen.
They come in their own metal baking pan, so there’s no extra dish to wash. The rolls are made with real butter and contain no preservatives or artificial flavors, according to their Walmart product listing.
If you want a heartier option, Sister Schubert’s Wheat Dinner Yeast Rolls are also worth a look. Eat This, Not That! ranked them among the healthiest rolls on shelves for their whole grains.
Rhodes Warm & Serve Soft White Rolls
Short on oven time? Rhodes is the answer. In Chowhound’s frozen roll test, the Warm & Serve rolls took the No. 1 spot for convenience, texture and taste.
There’s no rising required, unlike the brand’s regular dinner rolls, which need three to five hours. Just spread them on a baking sheet and bake for 12 to 14 minutes.
Testers said the rolls puffed up nicely and had a fluffy interior that could pass for homemade. That makes them a smart backup if your kitchen schedule goes off the rails.
Wegmans Dinner Rolls
Shoppers in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic have a store-brand gem close to home. The Daily Meal tasted 10 brands and ranked Wegmans’ rolls first.
The reviewer liked their balanced flavor, which is neither too sweet nor too savory. The rolls are small and fluffy and have only 3 grams of sugar. They’re also free of artificial colors, flavors and preservatives.
Nature’s Own Brioche-Style Butter Rolls
This widely available bread-aisle pick is a quiet favorite. An Insider writer who tried five brands named them her favorite store-bought roll, ahead of King’s Hawaiian.
She compared them to a buttery brioche: soft, slightly sweet and not too doughy. They tasted even better after a few minutes of warming, so pop them in the oven before serving.
How to Make Store-Bought Rolls Taste Homemade
A few small touches go a long way. Brush the tops with melted butter before warming, then sprinkle on flaky sea salt or chopped fresh herbs.
Serve the rolls warm in a cloth-lined basket to keep them soft. Set out good butter or a little honey butter, and your guests will never know you skipped the kneading.
