9 Store-Bought Gravies Worth Buying at US Supermarkets This Thanksgiving

thanksgiving gravyPin
Image via Canva
Share on:

Making gravy from scratch on Thanksgiving means juggling pan drippings, a whisk and a hot stovetop while the turkey rests and the guests get hungry. Fortunately, the grocery aisle has gotten a lot better at bottling that comfort. Food editors have spent the season pouring, whisking and tasting dozens of jars, cans and packets, and a handful of clear winners stand out.

Here are the store-bought gravies worth putting on your holiday table this year.

Better Than Gravy Roasted Turkey Gravy

61FpZyR9wAL. SL1000Pin
Image via Amazon

If you buy only one gravy this year, this one has the most backing. Food Network’s testers tried 15 store-bought turkey gravies over mashed potatoes and named this their best overall pick. They liked its strong, balanced turkey flavor and silky texture.

At roughly $2, it’s also very affordable. A separate tester who tried 17 gravies crowned it the jarred winner, saying it tasted like it was made from real drippings. It runs a little thinner than some rivals, so plan on simmering it a few extra minutes.

Buy on Amazon

Trader Joe’s Ready-to-Use Turkey Gravy

61RSR y73mL. SL1080Pin
Image via Amazon

Trader Joe’s shoppers have a seasonal favorite here. PureWow’s editor taste test ranked it best overall, giving it top scores for value and ease of use.

It isn’t for everyone, though. One writer at The Takeout placed it last in her lineup of jarred gravies, calling its flavor a bit odd next to the competition. Try a spoonful before the big day if you’re on the fence.

Buy on Amazon

Heinz HomeStyle Roasted Turkey Gravy

71zV2MKajwL. SL1500Pin
Image via Amazon

Heinz is pushing its gravy hard these days. The brand even ran a 2024 campaign declaring gravy “the new ketchup”, and the roasted turkey version backs up the hype.

PureWow called it the best choice to pour over turkey. Another reviewer was surprised enough to rank it second among eight jarred gravies, noting it had no floury aftertaste and wasn’t overly salty. You’ll find it at Walmart and most major supermarkets.

Buy on Amazon

Le Sauce Thanksgiving Turkey Gravy

61ASVCQXFSL. SL1080Pin
Image via Amazon

This is the pick for anyone who wants a gravy that tastes homemade. Eat This, Not That’s taste test named it the closest to homemade of the six gravies tried. It stood out for its rich, meaty flavor with notes of thyme and sage.

It costs about $6.89 for an 8.8-ounce pouch, so it’s a step up in price. It’s also thinner and easier to pour than most jarred options, which is a plus if you hate gloppy gravy.

Buy on Amazon

Williams Sonoma Turkey Gravy Base, Classic Recipe

img20cPin
Image via williams-sonoma.com

Hosting a crowd you want to impress? Food Network named this the best gourmet option, praising its smooth, homemade-like texture and restrained saltiness.

The catch is the price, about $18, and testers found the flavor a bit subdued for what you pay. It works best as a base: whisk in your turkey’s pan drippings and you’ll get a gravy that tastes like you made it yourself.

Signature Select Home Style Turkey Gravy

large 6a06ca8f ed40 4437 949b 279b2cbea58fPin
Image via Instacart.com

Shoppers at Safeway, Albertsons and their sister stores should grab a jar of this store brand. Simply Recipes testers named it their top ready-made gravy, praising its peppery taste and close-to-homemade quality.

Food Network named it the best value at around $2. Its testers were less excited, though, saying it lacked a distinct turkey flavor. Think of it as a dependable budget pick that gets better with a little extra seasoning.

Pioneer Roasted Turkey Gravy Mix

61TIAXX iRL. SL1200Pin
Image via Amazon

Packet gravies save pantry space and cost very little. Among them, Pioneer won Simply Recipes’ best turkey gravy mix title, with testers saying it tastes just like homemade.

Mixes take a few minutes of stovetop whisking, but you control the thickness. Use a splash of turkey stock in place of some of the water for deeper flavor.

Buy on Amazon

Knorr Roasted Turkey Gravy Mix

91KpDJGVDBL. SL1500Pin
Image via Amazon

Knorr took the best mix spot in Food Network’s 2026 testing. For about $1, testers got a creamy texture, an appealing brown color and a savory poultry aroma.

Two quick tips: it leans a little salty, and it needs frequent whisking to stay lump-free. Knorr’s brown gravy also has fans, with one Insider tester calling it the richest, most meaty option in a three-way test.

Buy on Amazon

Campbell’s Turkey Gravy

81raA85dY8L. SL1500Pin
Image via Amazon

The classic red-and-white can still has a place at the table. Food Network called it the best canned gravy for its rich, savory taste with no off-putting notes. PureWow singled it out as the best partner for mashed potatoes.

Don’t let the jiggly texture straight from the can put you off. It thins out nicely once heated and settles into a just-thick-enough consistency.

Buy on Amazon

Tips for Making Store-Bought Gravy Taste Homemade

Even the best jar benefits from a little help. Stir in some of the pan drippings from your roasted turkey, add fresh thyme or sage, and finish with a crack of black pepper. A small knob of butter whisked in at the end adds gloss and richness.

If you have guests with dietary needs, check labels carefully. Eat This, Not That’s runner-up, Primal Kitchen No Dairy Classic Gravy, is certified organic, keto, Whole30 and paleo-friendly.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted