7 Northern Virginia Bakeries and Shops Taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders in 2026
Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, and the best Northern Virginia pie orders close days before the holiday. Several shops haven’t posted deadlines yet, so a phone call is part of the plan.
Ashburn has few bakeries with posted holiday details. This list starts there and reaches into Leesburg, Herndon, and Arlington. Prices are the latest published figures, so check the shop before you pay.
The Difference Baker
The Difference Baker is an allergy-free bakery. A 2026 pie roundup lists locations in Ashburn, Sterling, and Fairfax, and a pumpkin pie tart, an apple pie tart, and pumpkin rolls.
The shop’s order page asks for one week’s notice. For Thanksgiving, that points to around Nov. 19.
Add your pickup date in the special instructions at checkout. Prices for the holiday items weren’t posted.
Mom’s Apple Pie Company
Mom’s is the Loudoun County classic, with shops in Leesburg and Round Hill. The locations page lists daily hours but no holiday order details.
Call the Leesburg shop at 703-771-8590 or email [email protected] to ask about Thanksgiving pre-orders. One Northern Virginia magazine guide lists signature apple and chocolate pecan pies, though that page carries no date.
That makes apple the safe first ask.
Founding Farmers
Founding Farmers sells whole pies at its Reston Station, Tysons, and Alexandria restaurants. The restaurant’s page lists whole pies at $45 or slices at $8.99.
Cheesecakes are $65 whole or $12.99 a slice. Whole pies and cakes need at least 36 hours’ notice.
An undated regional guide lists apple, pumpkin, and pecan. Confirm the current flavors when you order.
Amphora Bakery
Amphora is a Herndon bakery with a long menu. A 2026 roundup says it offers dozens of flavors, including apple, pumpkin, Bonfire S’mores, and Butterscotch Heath Bar.
Its pumpkin pie page lists $26.95 and tags it a Thanksgiving pie. Sizes, deadlines, and pickup dates weren’t listed.
Call before you plan around a date.
Creme de la Crop
Creme de la Crop in Herndon makes ice cream pies without dairy, gluten, or soy. The same 2026 roundup lists pumpkin meringue, chocolate butter pecan, and caramel apple.
It suits tables with allergies. Prices and deadlines weren’t posted this year, so ask the shop.
Bakeshop
Bakeshop has locations in Arlington, Falls Church, and Vienna. The roundup lists apple, pumpkin, pecan, and bourbon chocolate pecan with an all-butter crust.
It also lists a vegan pumpkin pie and icebox classics. Pie prices aren’t posted.
Per the shop’s order page, you can place non-cake orders by phone, and each location takes online orders.
Northside Social
Northside Social in Arlington and Falls Church sells nine-inch pies that serve six to eight. The same roundup lists apple cinnamon, maple pumpkin, brown sugar pecan, and chocolate chip espresso cookie dough.
The cookie dough pie is the unusual one. Prices and deadlines weren’t listed.
A note on reviews: holiday pie sales get little diner feedback this early. Flavor picks come from each shop’s posted menu and one regional roundup.
