7 New York City Bakeries and Shops Taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders in 2026
Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, and New York’s best pie orders close well before the holiday. Some deadlines are only days away.
These seven shops have posted 2026 details, though a few are still being updated. Prices are the latest published figures, so check the shop before you pay.
Petee’s Pie Co.
Petee’s takes Thanksgiving orders online through its holiday ordering page. The order deadline is Sunday, Nov. 22.
Pickup runs Monday, Nov. 23 through Thursday, Nov. 26, and delivery is Nov. 23 and 24. There are pickup counters on the Lower East Side and at 505 Myrtle Ave. in Brooklyn.
The page lists Hudson Valley heirloom apple, farm-fresh pumpkin, and sweet potato at $45. Holiday pricing wasn’t confirmed, so check at checkout.
A 2023 roundup from Secret NYC called it the best pie in the city. It recommends the pumpkin, the Hudson Valley apple, and the brown butter honey pecan.
Bubby’s
Bubby’s in Tribeca sells pies with an order deadline of Nov. 20. The Infatuation’s 2026 pie guide lists sour cherry, pumpkin praline, and pecan maple at $50 each.
Pickup is Nov. 24 or 25.
Pumpkin praline is the pick for people who want extra pumpkin flavor. PureWow’s 2023 list also recommends it and calls the chocolate peanut butter pie legendary.
Bubby’s also sells takeout packages that serve two, for $200. Pickup is Nov. 26 from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., according to The Infatuation.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
The Gowanus shop is the one to know in Brooklyn. The Infatuation lists salted caramel apple, brown butter pumpkin, bittersweet chocolate pecan, and salty honey at $46 for a 10-inch pie.
The shop’s own page shows a nine-inch pie at $45. It also says walk-in pies are first come, first served from Nov. 21 through 23 and during Thanksgiving week.
That page also says pre-orders may be sold out and doesn’t print a year. Check the shop before you plan around it.
The salty honey pie is the one to try. PureWow’s 2023 roundup says skipping it is doing yourself a disservice.
The shop closes at 3 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day.
Dominique Ansel Bakery
Dominique Ansel’s SoHo bakery has three Thanksgiving pies. The Infatuation lists extra silky pumpkin and bourbon pecan at $70 each, and salted caramel apple at $72.
Pickup is Nov. 20 through 26, according to that guide.
The shop’s own apple pie page still showed last year’s dates when checked. It says to order at least two days before pickup, so confirm the 2026 window before you order.
The 2023 Secret NYC roundup suggests the salted caramel apple or the bourbon pecan.
Maman
Maman is the budget pick on this list. The Midtown café lists classic pecan, pumpkin with whipped mascarpone cream cheese, and spiced apple crumb at $39 each.
Each pie serves 8 to 10 people. Orders are placed by email, and pickup is Nov. 24 through 26.
The pumpkin with mascarpone is the unusual one. Secret NYC’s 2023 roundup also highlights it alongside the pecan and apple.
Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods
Janie’s sells three pies at $45 each, according to DoNYC’s Thanksgiving guide. They are caramel apple, chocolate pecan, and sticky toffee pumpkin.
Orders are preorder only. Pickup is Nov. 24 and 25 at select locations, including East Harlem and the Upper West Side.
The sticky toffee pumpkin is the twist on the classic. The guide doesn’t say which pie is the best seller, so ask the shop.
Orwashers Bakery
Orwashers sells pumpkin pie with a pumpkin crumble, pecan, and apple. The Infatuation lists pickup on Nov. 22 through 26 at the Upper East Side and Upper West Side shops.
Prices and deadlines weren’t listed, so call or check the shop’s site. The pumpkin with crumble is the first one on the list.
A note on reviews: these shops post pickup details more than diner feedback this early. Flavor picks come from 2023 pie roundups and the shops’ own listings.
