7 Boston Bakeries and Shops Taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders in 2026
Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, and Boston’s best pie orders close well before the holiday. Several deadlines land within the week.
These seven sellers have posted 2026 details. Prices are the latest published figures, so check the shop before you pay.
Flour Bakery + Cafe
Flour’s Thanksgiving page lists pies, cakes, rolls, and sides. Delivery orders close at 4 p.m. on Saturday, Nov. 21, while supplies last.
Pies run from classic pumpkin at $30 to double-crust apple at $40. Southern pecan and sweet potato are $35, and the Piefecta is $38.
There are also gluten-free versions of the pumpkin pie at $35 and the chocolate cream at $45. A 2026 roundup lists pickup on Tuesday, Nov. 24 or Wednesday, Nov. 25.
The Piefecta is the one to ask about. A 2023 guide described it as a pecan and pumpkin combination.
Formaggio Kitchen
Formaggio’s Thanksgiving order form offers apple, pumpkin, and pecan pies. Orders are due by 4 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 20.
Pickup is Tuesday, Nov. 24 or Wednesday, Nov. 25. The same menu is available at the Huron Village, South End, and Kendall Square shops.
One guide lists pumpkin at $38, and apple and chocolate-bourbon pecan at $45. Each serves about eight.
You can order online, by printed form, or by phone.
Petsi Pies
Petsi in Somerville takes no pre-orders this year. A 2026 guide says pies are walk-in only.
The shop is open Tuesday, Nov. 24 from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. On Wednesday, Nov. 25, it opens at 8 a.m. and sells until pies run out.
Flavors change by batch, and none are posted. Get there early on Wednesday.
The Infatuation says the shop turned a self-described non-pie person into a fan. Its review names the salted caramel apple and the sweet potato pecan.
Clear Flour Bread
Clear Flour in Brookline is another walk-in stop. According to one guide, there are no holiday pre-orders.
The apple crumble is listed for Nov. 23 through 25. The same guide also mentions an apple-cranberry tart and other seasonal baking.
Prices aren’t listed. Check the shop’s holiday hours before you go.
Pie in the Sky
Pie in the Sky is a fundraiser for Community Servings. The Boston Globe says this is its 34th year.
Pies are $37 each, in apple, pecan, or pumpkin. A bundle includes all three, and the pies may come from different bakers.
Orders close Nov. 21 online at pieinthesky.org or through a volunteer. Pickup is Tuesday, Nov. 24 at dozens of sites across eastern Massachusetts, and you choose the site when you order.
The Globe names Flour Bakery, Petsi Pies, Modern Pastry, Davio’s, Mistral, and Boston Baking of Hyde Park among the participants.
Baker’s Best
Baker’s Best in Needham has a short window. A 2026 roundup lists pies at $34, with orders due by noon on Monday, Nov. 16.
Pickup or delivery is Nov. 24 and 25. Flavors aren’t listed, so ask when you order.
This is the nearest deadline in the article. Call the shop first.
Summer Shack
Summer Shack in Cambridge is a seafood restaurant that sells whole pies for the holiday. The same guide lists apple, pumpkin, or pecan at $30 each.
Pickup is Wednesday, Nov. 25 from noon to 6 p.m. No cutoff date is posted, so call before you count on one.
A note on reviews: holiday pie sales get little diner feedback this early. The picks above come from each seller’s posted menu and one review of Petsi.
