3 Musketeers vs. Baby Ruth: Differences & Which Is Better?

3 musketeers vs baby ruth
Share on:

You have probably tried many chocolate bars, and many of them have tested similarly, so you have never had the chance to determine which one is the best. If you have tried the 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth, you may have noticed that they have somehow similar flavors and ingredients, but not exactly the same. That’s why I wrote everything you need to know about the differences between 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth. 

Both 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth chocolate bars have chocolate nougat included in their content; therefore, they have similar tastes and flavors. However, one major difference is evident between the two – the presence of caramel and peanuts in Baby Ruth, ingredients that are missing from 3 Musketeers.

If you are interested in learning something more about the differences between 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth, you have come to the right place. I have explained all the differences between these two chocolate bars in terms of ingredients, nutrition, popularity, ownership, and prices. I have also discussed the history of these two heavenly sweets, so you will know which one was the first to dominate the market of chocolate bars. 

3 Musketeers vs. Baby Ruth: Comparison

Although 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth chocolate bars include some of the same ingredients in their content, there are still some very important differences according to which people opt for one or the other.

 In order to better understand these differences, you have to look closely at their ingredients and nutritional values, so you would be aware of what makes them distinct. Besides these facts, it would also be beneficial to compare their prices and popularity levels and understand which one is better. 

Taste and Flavors 

Both 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth are commonly chosen for the generous amount of nougat inside them. People who enjoy nougat cannot resist these chocolate bars because this is the dominant flavor in them. However, there is one big difference when it comes to other tastes of these chocolate bars. 

Namely, 3 Musketeers is filled mostly with nougat in the center, therefore, when you bite the bar, this is the first flavor that you are going to taste. On the other hand, besides nougat, Baby Ruth includes caramel and peanuts as well. The combination of these two ingredients, along with the nougat, gives the chocolate bar a quite unique taste, so people who like peanuts and caramel mixed with chocolate would probably opt for Baby Ruth.

In other words, the combination and the caramel give quite different tastes when accompanied with nougat, although nougat is usually the dominant flavor. Therefore, many people opt for Baby Ruth when they want a more delicate taste of the chocolate bar. 


Like most chocolate bars, Baby Ruth and 3 Musketeers share the same ingredients, such as chocolate, sugar, milk, corn syrup, and salt. That is why when you take a bite of both, they might remind you of one another. However, certain ingredients make their taste unique and recognizable, and those particular ingredients are why people opt for one of them. 

Therefore, 3 Musketeers contain other ingredients, such as cocoa powder, oil, and egg whites along with the basic ones mentioned before. However, the special thing about this chocolate bar is that it contains a lot of natural flavors among artificial ones. Natural flavors have a special way of making the taste better, and that is why they are chosen in the content of 3 Musketeers. 

On the other hand, the special thing about Baby Ruth is the amazing combination of peanuts and caramel. The generous addition of creamy caramel and the crunchiness provided by the peanuts is what makes this chocolate bar so tasty. This means that a single ingredient can make a significant difference in the taste of a chocolate bar, and that is the reason why you should make your choice wisely and carefully. 


If we compare the nutritional values of regular sizes of these chocolate bars, the first difference that can be noticed is the number of calories included in each. That is, while 3 Musketeers contains 240 calories, Baby Ruth contains 260. In addition, the presence of sodium is higher in 3 Musketeers than in Baby Ruth. [1] [2]

However, when it comes to carbs, it is noted that 3 Musketeers includes more calories than Baby Ruth, and the percentage of protein is higher in the latter than in the former. The protein amount in Baby Ruth is understandable since his chocolate bar contains peanuts, which are the main source of protein. Therefore, if you want to choose something that is healthier, the better option would probably be Baby Ruth. 


It is sometimes strange to hear that these two chocolate bars do not come from the same manufacturer, even though they might taste similarly due to some of the same ingredients. 

3 Musketeers is a product by Mars Wrigley, a widely known chocolate company worldwide, but Baby Ruth comes from Ferrara Candy Company, which is as popular as Mars, Inc. However, when it comes to the territory of the US, both chocolate bars are widely spread and consumed among millions of people. 

Which Came First?

Baby Ruth was the first chocolate bar between the two since it first came out in 1920. 3 Musketeers came years later in 1932, but it has undergone many changes over the years. This version that we know today was a lot altered from the one that came out in 1932. 

Since tastes cannot be discussed, it would be difficult to say that one is better than the other. However, one thing is for sure – both 3 Musketeers and Baby Ruth are quite popular and they are known as some of the most delicious chocolate bars across the world. 


If we talk about the US, then it can be said that both of the chocolate bars are quite popular. However, it would be fair to say that 3 Musketeers might be slightly more popular than Baby Ruth because, firstly, it is more spread around the world, and secondly, it holds a standard that was built a long time ago. Sometimes, the standard and the reputation of a chocolate bar do not measure the quality of the taste, but in this case, this rule applies.

Final Thoughts: Which One to Choose, 3 Musketeers or Baby Ruth? 

If your option is dictated basically by the taste of the chocolate bar, then you should choose what better suits your palate. In other words, if you feel like eating something crunchy and creamy, then you better opt for Baby Ruth. On the other hand, if you just want to feel some nougat on your palate, then it would be better to go for 3 Musketeers. 

However, if you are trying to find a healthier option, then it would be better to go for Baby Ruth since it contains a higher amount of protein and fewer carbs.